26 February 2015
BEE RUSTLING!?
Bee
Rustling? Recent events have drawn a lot
of attention to the crime of bee rustling.
But, when most first hear about bee rustling . . . well, let’s just say
that this crime seems to spring up out “out of left field.” Rustling is the theft of livestock. And honeybees are, legally, treated like livestock in many jurisdictions. Sometimes "rustling" is used to describe the theft of hives with the bees inside. Then, "theft" is used to describe removing the bees from the hive and carrying them off. But there's no real consistency in the names given to the crimes.
Live-stock
rustling is old . . . very old and, apparently, common to almost every culture
on earth. Rustling isn’t hard to
understand. A person’s or community’s
livestock are a valuable resource.
Cattle are raised for meat and dairy products as well as providing
leather for clothing. Sheep are also
raised for their meat, but provide wool for cloth and clothing. Even ostriches are raised for their feathers
(factoid: these very large birds can be repeatedly sheered for their feathers like sheep
are sheered for wool).
HOW, EXACTLY, DO BEES
GET “RUSTLED”?
Actually, there are two ways to rustle by honeybees.
The first can involve nothing more than pulling up in a truck and taking
some standing hives. Beehives must be
kept in the open for the benefit of the activities of their insect occupants (pollination
and honey-making). Taking whole hives to
another location is about the fastest way to do the crime.
But there’s
another, more complicated but, surprisingly, popular way to do the crime and
conceal your doings at the same time. If
you don’t want the theft detected, you open the hive and remove the “valuable”
parts and leave the rest behind.
What
are the valuable parts? (1) The queen – the
mother of every bee in the hive . . .
and . . . (2) the brood comb. The
brood comb is the nursery housing the next generation of worker bees and
queens. After you've taken the queen and brood comb, you can leave the rest behind
and re-close the hive. Weeks may pass
before anyone will be able to tell that the colony is dying.
But doesn't the bee-rustler want to take the honey?
Actually,
no. The bees will make more of that quickly
enough. And rustlers often aren’t after
honey-money anyway.
HOW TO GET RICH
KEEPING BEES
The best
way to understand bee rustling is to remember exactly what ranchers hope to
gain by raising livestock.
Money.
But is
there that much money in honey?
The answer
to that question is, most often,
“no.” But most of the money in modern commercial beekeeping isn’t
from honey anymore. About 40 years ago,
a beekeeper might ask local farmers to allow hives to be placed near their
farms’ crops. Sometimes, beekeepers were
even forced to pay farmers to allow pollinating honeybees near a farm’s
crops. After all, the bees would use the
pollen to make honey. What could the
farmer expect to get out the deal?
Fast-forward
40 years.
Bees are in
short supply in agriculture.
Particularly large farm operations are absolutely dependent on their crops
producing seed for the next season. Even more significantly, without pollination, many plants
and trees won’t produce fruit at all.
And fruit production is very profitable.
But there
are also nuts. The nut is called the almond, one of America’s most profitable cash
crops. Without bees, few almonds
would be produced. Problem? Bees are in short supply and almond growers need
pollinators.
FARMING CHANGED
We hear a lot today about
declining bee populations in North America and Europe. But, surprisingly, the pollinator
shortage wasn’t caused by declining populations -- at least not in the beginning. Instead, agricultural operations, the farms, grew in size
and, then, grew and grew and grew some more. The
profitability of almond production rose so much that California’s almond orchards
have grown from thousands to millions of acres in just a few decades.
Even before honeybee populations began to
decline, the growth of agriculture outpaced the growth of honeybee populations. So, in the beginning, the bees weren’t dying, the
farms were growing. Only, later, did bee
populations begin to decline.
Considering the growth of agricultural demand, the news that honeybee population were declining was met with tremendous concern by growers. Admittedly, the growers' view of "shortage" is a bit different that the naturalists' view. To the growers, declining bee population, mean expense. The fewer bees, the more it costs growers to lease the services of those available. To date, there remain enough bees to go around, but as bee populations move downward, the price of renting the bees goes up. Of course, commercial beekeepers are getting "the long end of stick," as individual hive rental prices climb higher and higher.
BEEKEEPING BECOMES
BIG MONEY
Beekeeping “old timers” will
speak of the days when it was struggle just to keep body and soul together in the
beekeeping business. There’s always been
a healthy demand for honey, but not so much profit that beekeeping didn’t have
its good times and bad.
Now, almost
every commercial beekeeper in the United States leases their bees out as
“pollinators.” And almost every
commercial beekeeper in America will visit the almond orchards of California
this spring – as they have for many springs past. How much can you make per hive. Well, you can get paid $200.00 for rental of
one hive for just a few days. And, when
the smoke clears, you’ll likely have made almost $100.00 profit over and above
all your costs.
Oh, there's something else. . . . How many hives does
a single beekeeper bring to the almond orchards in the spring? The larger operators bring 10,000 to 20,000 hives. We’re not just talking serious money. We’re talking serious net profit.
HOW TO MAKE EVEN MORE FROM EACH HIVE
But wouldn’t it be great if you
didn’t have any costs. If the $200
rental fee per hive went right into you pocket without any investment of time,
materials and effort. It’s a nice
dream. Money for nothing.
Well, honeybee
rustlers have found a way to make that dream a reality. Let the beekeeper/owner of the hive bear the
costs. All the rustler has to do is hit
the road in January of each year (just before the almond pollination season). Troll the areas around the almond
fields. No one can watch all those hives
every minute of the day and night. When
no one’s looking, just pick up a few (or a lot of) hives.
Spring in
the almond fields is a wild time with growers and beekeepers trying to connect
during a short season. There will be
short-falls when some expected bees fail to arrive. Filling those unexpected gaps isn’t just a
good market, it’s a great one. At the
last minute, a rustler may be able to rent their stolen hives out for more than the
average market price. And the rustlers don’t even
have to come back to pick the hives up. They can just
take the money and run.
BIG MONEY ATTRACTS
ATTENTION
If you understand beekeeping
and bee behavior, this sort of rustling can be easy. But to pull off this “steal and lease”
operation you have to stick with the “quick” type of theft. You take the whole hive. You can’t pause to take parts of the hive,
install them in your own hives and wait for them to mature.
The problem
with stealing the whole hives, for the rustler, is that it increases the chances of getting caught. Most hives have names branded into the wood
and serial numbers attached. The serial
numbers are assigned by beekeepers as a group working through their own
association. But even with these
identifiers, bee rustlers do just what
auto thieves do. They file off the
brands and numbers. Still, they may get
caught in the process or the hives may be recognized by color or design.
A
government sponsored national registration system for hives might help. But all the added record keeping will only help
recovery, not prevent theft. A GPS
solution has been proposed with a system sensitive enough to detect the
relatively small surface movements that a bee rustler might make in stealing
and leasing a hive to an unsuspecting grower. But these distances
are small enough that a sensitive system is required. The needed GPS units are really too big to be
conveniently installed in your average hive.
And, when you’re dealing with hives numbering in the thousands, GPS
units become too expensive.
For now,
business is profitable enough, and rustling limited enough, to allow most beekeepers to absorb rustling loses. But as farms
expand and bee populations decline, the rental value of each hive
increases. And every increase in value
adds to profits -- on the "up" side. But there's also a "down" side. Each hive becomes more tempting to bee rustlers .
Unfortunately,
honeybee rustling is a crime that seems to have a future.
With the agricultural industry constantly increasing in size and bee populations steadily decreasing, the value of honeybees as pollinators isn’t
expected to decline any time soon.